+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
Results 26 to 39 of 39

Thread: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

  1. #26
    Dom
    Dom is offline
    MIGClub Member Dom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    Northants
    Posts
    20,520
    Drives
    73bhp MK4 Astra POS

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    I always understood it was to let the turbo cool down for a sufficient period so as not to "cook" the oil that would be left in it once the oil pump had stopped.
    Doms online shop - www.picbits.co.uk/catalog,bulbs,cable,heatshrink etc
    Please don't ask for general advice by Private Messages - PMs are for PRIVATE MESSAGES. General advice should be asked on the Forums !

  2. Remove Advertisements
    MigWeb.co.uk
    Advertisements
     

  3. #27
    Dom
    Dom is offline
    MIGClub Member Dom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    Northants
    Posts
    20,520
    Drives
    73bhp MK4 Astra POS

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    And not saying Wikipedia is always right but it backs up everything I've been told about the matter:

    Quote Originally Posted by Wikipedia
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    Jump to: navigation, search
    A turbo timer is a device designed to keep an automotive engine running for a pre-specified period of time in order to automatically execute the cool-down period required to prevent premature turbo wear and failure. After a period of driving when a turbocharger has been working hard, it is important to let the engine run at idle speed for a period of time, allowing the compressor assembly to cool from the lower gas temperatures in both the exhaust and intake tracts. At the same time the lubricating oil from the engine is able to circulate properly so the turbine won't burn the lubricating oil that would otherwise be trapped within the charger with the turbine rotating at high speed. With regard to modern automotive turbochargers, the need for a turbo timer can be eliminated by simply ensuring the car does not produce any 'boost' (during driving) for several minutes prior to the ignition being shut off. Most turbo timers are based on digital electronics.

    Turbo timers can usually be disabled by an external switch, this is normally done using the handbrake switch, or using an automatic one.
    Doms online shop - www.picbits.co.uk/catalog,bulbs,cable,heatshrink etc
    Please don't ask for general advice by Private Messages - PMs are for PRIVATE MESSAGES. General advice should be asked on the Forums !

  4. #28
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    derby
    Posts
    1,345
    Drives
    cav 93 sri red top

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    So many answers all saying the same.... Guess I must be off the mark....

    Note to self;

    1, Turbo Timers are employed to permit a turbo to cool....
    2, Turbo Timers are employed to prevent oil 'coking' the insides of the turbo housing & bearings....

    3, Turbo Timers are not employed to permit a fully lubricated & cooled spooling down period....
    4, Turbo bearings are not affected by friction during extended unlubricated spooling down periods....
    5, Turbo bearings are not affected by heat build up during uncooled & unlubricated extended spooling down periods because they don't suffer increased friction when unlubricated....
    6, Technology with regards turbos, bearings & engine oil has stood still for nearly 30 years....
    7, Turbine speed is always in tune to engine speed, both friction & inertia are banned from turbos....
    8, Inertia plays no part in a turbines spooling down period....
    9, Low inertia turbos are a myth....
    10, Lighter ceramic turbine blades have no beneficial effects as inertia & friction don't exist within a turbo....
    11, Turbo lag is a myth....

    Nuff said... I'm totally wrong and talking out my anal orifice....

    WALLY one signing off.........
    if it sounds right to you, then its right.

  5. #29
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    birmingham
    Posts
    127
    Drives
    8v Corsa

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    the saxo probly had its spare key in with it running lmao

  6. #30
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Cheshire
    Posts
    318
    Drives
    Golf Mk4, AstraVan

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    I always like the cheap simple solution...... lmao

    I am currently learning to manually wind my windows up and down smoothly so they look electric, and I turn my lights on when entering a tunnel and off again when leaving, and wipe my windows pointlessly on perfectly dry days, turn my engine off at traffic lights.... and ... and ... oh please stop me......
    “Speed has never killed anyone, suddenly becoming stationary… that’s what gets you.”

  7. #31
    MIGClub Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Cirencester, Glos
    Posts
    3,703
    Drives
    GTE 16v Turbo

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by Dom View Post
    I always understood it was to let the turbo cool down for a sufficient period so as not to "cook" the oil that would be left in it once the oil pump had stopped.
    That's as I understand it too. In fact an old Toyota Avensis TD I had as a company car had a warning sticker on the sun visor saying it was equipped with a turbocharger therefore it was advised to run the car at idle for a minute after normal use to allow for adequate cooling down therefore extending bearing life.
    "When this baby hits 88 miles per hour. You're gonna see some serious s***"!!!!!!

  8. #32
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    ipswich
    Posts
    260
    Drives
    C20LET mk3 astra

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by wallopsri View Post
    So many answers all saying the same.... Guess I must be off the mark....

    Note to self;

    1, Turbo Timers are employed to permit a turbo to cool....
    2, Turbo Timers are employed to prevent oil 'coking' the insides of the turbo housing & bearings....

    3, Turbo Timers are not employed to permit a fully lubricated & cooled spooling down period....
    4, Turbo bearings are not affected by friction during extended unlubricated spooling down periods....
    5, Turbo bearings are not affected by heat build up during uncooled & unlubricated extended spooling down periods because they don't suffer increased friction when unlubricated....
    6, Technology with regards turbos, bearings & engine oil has stood still for nearly 30 years....
    7, Turbine speed is always in tune to engine speed, both friction & inertia are banned from turbos....
    8, Inertia plays no part in a turbines spooling down period....
    9, Low inertia turbos are a myth....
    10, Lighter ceramic turbine blades have no beneficial effects as inertia & friction don't exist within a turbo....
    11, Turbo lag is a myth....

    Nuff said... I'm totally wrong and talking out my anal orifice....

    WALLY one signing off.........


    where as before you just sounded like someone who has been told the wrong information at some point... now you have made yourself sound like a right idiot lmao

    turbo timers are for allowing the turbo to cool down and and prevent coking and thats it, sh*t bust.

    yes, if you ran the turbo up to full boost and then cut the oil supply off there would be increased wear but that is a totaly different senario.

    you are trying to say that a turbo takes minutes to slow down when it quite simply doesnt! if it did rally cars would not need anti lag to keep the turbo spooled up during gear changes etc...

    the reality is that it only takes a few seconds for a turbo to return to idle speed. by the time you've parked the car and got round to turning the engine off the turbo will have slowed down so no matter how long you keep the engine running the wear on shutdown will be the same

    a slight exeption would be roller bearing turbos as they take longer to slow down but they still dont take long, and even if they were still spinning slightly faster than idle speed when you turned the engine off, the wear would be minimal because they have roller bearings (clues in the name ) and the residual oil in the bearings would be enough to keep them lubricated untill the turbo had stoped

    also on your points 6,7,8,9+10... lighter/low inertia turbos are desighed to help spool up, nothing to do with shutting the engine off. and ironicly, due to their low inertia, would spool down faster so would be at even less risk of your so called increased wear lmao

    and yes oil technology has moved on in the last 30 years. hence not that many people use turbo times these days as modern oils are more resistant to coking. people that still use them normaly just have them for piece of mind, something else to ad to the gadget list or from miss information from people like you
    Last edited by jordanb7426; 03-04-2010 at 17:28.

  9. #33
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Auckland, New Zealan
    Posts
    3,521
    Drives
    Chevette XE, Calibra

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by wallopsri View Post
    Chill out mate.... I'm not simply regurgitating crap read off the net....
    Just crap!
    If you give the engine a big rev' and immediately shut it down, the turbine may run dry, but normally it's turning slowly, oil pressure doesn't drop immediately and there's a residual oil film to lubricate it.
    500C will cook ANY modern oil, continuing an oil supply will make a significant reduction in the bearing temperature. As will, surprisingly, the idle temperature exhaust gases.

    That said, for normal. light driving, a timer is probably not needed - it's more for when a vehicle is driven hard and then shut down with the turbo still very hot.

  10. #34
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Auckland, New Zealan
    Posts
    3,521
    Drives
    Chevette XE, Calibra

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by wallopsri View Post
    So many answers all saying the same.... Guess I must be off the mark....

    Note to self;

    1, Turbo Timers are employed to permit a turbo to cool.... true
    2, Turbo Timers are employed to prevent oil 'coking' the insides of the turbo housing & bearings.... true

    3, Turbo Timers are not employed to permit a fully lubricated & cooled spooling down period.... don't be stupid!
    4, Turbo bearings are not affected by friction during extended unlubricated spooling down periods.... of course they are - don't play dumb!
    5, Turbo bearings are not affected by heat build up during uncooled & unlubricated extended spooling down periods because they don't suffer increased friction when unlubricated.... see above
    6, Technology with regards turbos, bearings & engine oil has stood still for nearly 30 years.... see above
    7, Turbine speed is always in tune to engine speed, both friction & inertia are banned from turbos.... false, false and false - as you know!
    8, Inertia plays no part in a turbines spooling down period.... see above
    9, Low inertia turbos are a myth.... see above
    10, Lighter ceramic turbine blades have no beneficial effects as inertia & friction don't exist within a turbo.... see above
    11, Turbo lag is a myth.... see above

    Nuff said... I'm totally wrong and talking out my anal orifice....

    WALLY one signing off.........
    Not totally wrong - you got the first two right!

  11. #35
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    derby
    Posts
    1,345
    Drives
    cav 93 sri red top

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Chill out guys....

    Sarcastic posts are supposed to be taken in jest.... Please accept my humble apologies if my post wasn't quite easily understood....

    Be careful on those high horses lads....lmao

    Wally one signing off...
    if it sounds right to you, then its right.

  12. #36
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    ipswich
    Posts
    260
    Drives
    C20LET mk3 astra

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by Gordo View Post
    Not totally wrong - you got the first two right!
    lmao

  13. #37
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    derby
    Posts
    1,345
    Drives
    cav 93 sri red top

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by Gordo View Post
    Not totally wrong - you got the first two right!
    Now thats funny.... Cheers you've brightened an otherwise boring daylmao
    if it sounds right to you, then its right.

  14. #38
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    suffolk
    Posts
    8,957
    Drives
    Corsa Tbo KTM SMoto

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    apologie accepted
    www.wix.com/vxlgsi/zxr-750-r

  15. #39
    MIGWeb User
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    ipswich
    Posts
    260
    Drives
    C20LET mk3 astra

    Re: Delayed engine shutoff WTF!!!

    Quote Originally Posted by vxlgsi View Post
    apologie accepted
    +1

    its not that we want to make you look stupid. its just like vxlgsi said before, theres a lot of myths and false info about on the net and we want to make sure people get the right information

    every days a school day

+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts